Carney isn’t trying to fix the carbon tax problem. He’s just trying to hide it
For interview requests, click here
Liberal leadership candidate Mark Carney seems to think giving you a discount code on a new furnace or some extra insulation is the best way to help with affordability.
And he’s going to pay for those discounts by hitting businesses like fuel refineries and power plants with a hidden carbon tax. Of course, those businesses will just pass on the cost.
Bottom line: You still get hit with that hidden carbon tax when you buy gas or pay your bills.
But it gets worse.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau at least attempted to give you some of the carbon tax money back through rebates. The parliamentary budget officer consistently made it clear the rebates don’t cover all the costs. But at least you could spend the money on the things you need most.
 Mark Carney wants you to pay more carbon tax without realizing it. |
| Recommended |
| Carbon pricing is finally hitting the political wall. So what comes next?
|
| The carbon tax is crushing Canadians. Enough Is enough
|
| Trudeau hiking taxes again in 2025
|
Under Carney’s “affordability” plan, you don’t get cash to pay down your credit card or buy groceries. You can only use the credits to buy things like e-bikes and heat pumps.
Here’s how Carney explained it:
“We will have the big polluters pay for climate incentives by developing and integrating a new consumer carbon credit market into the industrial pricing system,” Carney told a Halifax crowd. “While we still provide price certainty for households when they make climate smart choices.”
Translation: Carney would still make Canadians pay, but he’ll only help them with affordability if they’re making “smart” choices.
Sound familiar? This is a lot like the scheme former Conservative Party leader Erin O’Toole ran on. And it ended his political career.
Carney’s carbon tax plan is terrible for two reasons.
First, it’s sneaky. Carney wants to hide the cost of the carbon tax. A power plant running on natural gas is not going to eat the cost of Carney’s carbon tax; it will pass that expense down to ordinary people who are paying the bills.
Second, as anemic as the Trudeau government rebates are, at least Canadians could use the money for the things they need most. It’s cash they can put toward the next heating bill, buy a pair of winter boots, or pay for birthday party decorations.
That kind of messy freedom makes some central planning politicians twitchy.
Here’s the thing: half of Canadians are broke, and a discount on a new Tesla probably won’t solve their problems.
About 50 per cent are within $200 each month of not being able to make the minimum payments on their bills.
With the cost of groceries up $800 this year for a family of four, people are watching flyers for peanut butter. Food banks have record demand.
Yet, Carney wants Canadians to keep paying the carbon tax while blindfolded and then send thank-you cards when they get a few bucks off on a solar panel they can’t afford.
Clearly, the architects of Carney’s plan haven’t spent many sleepless nights worrying about paying rent.
One of Carney’s recent gigs was as governor of the Bank of England, where he was paid $862,000 per year plus a $449,000 housing allowance.
With ermine earmuffs that thick, it’s hard to hear people’s worries.
About a thousand Canadians recently posted home heating bills online.
Kelly’s family in northern Ontario paid $134 in carbon tax for December’s home heating. Lilly’s household bill near Winnipeg was $140 in carbon tax.
The average Alberta household will pay about $440 extra in carbon tax on home heating this year.
After the carbon tax is hiked April 1, it will add an extra 21 cents per litre of gasoline and 25 cents per litre of diesel. Filling a minivan will cost about $15 extra, filling a pickup truck will cost about $25 extra, and a trucker filling a big rig will have to pay about $250 extra in carbon tax.
Trudeau’s carbon tax data is posted online.
Carney’s carbon tax would be hidden.
Carney isn’t saying the carbon tax is an unfair punishment for Canadians trying to drive to work and heat their homes. He says the problem is “perception.”
“It has become very divisive for Canadians,” Carney told his Halifax crowd about the carbon tax. “It’s the perceptions of the negative impacts of the carbon tax on households, without fully recognizing the positive impacts of the rebate.”
Carney isn’t trying to fix the problem. He’s trying to hide it. And he wants Canadians to be happy with discount codes on “smart” purchases instead of cash.
Kris Sims is the Alberta Director for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
Explore more on Carbon tax, Liberal Party, Federal taxes, Taxes, Cost of living, Canadian economy
Troy Media is dedicated to empowering Canadian community news outlets by providing independent, insightful analysis and commentary. Our mission is to support local media in fostering an informed and engaged public by delivering reliable content that strengthens community connections, enriches national conversations, and helps Canadians better understand one another.
